|
AMBULATORY CARE
New Medicare Drug Coverage Proposed For Low-Income
Beneficiaries
Almost half of Medicare enrollees currently
have no prescription drug coverage. Unable to afford supplemental
insurance, low-income patients frequently stretch existing medications
to the point of ineffectiveness or choose not to fill expensive
prescriptions, putting their health on the line.
 |
| Stephen Soumerai
(r) and Dennis Ross-Degnan propose a joint federalstate
program to cover outpatient prescription drugs for low-income
Medicare beneficiaries. |
|
In the March 4 New England Journal of Medicine, drug policy
and health services experts Stephen Soumerai and Dennis Ross-Degnan
describe the economic and clinical consequences of medication underuse
and outline an incremental federal and state policy reform that
would improve low-income Medicare patients' access to key medications.
The Drug Coverage Gap
In Medicare's 34 years of existence, the basic federal health
insurance program for seniors and disabled people has never paid
for outpatient drugs. Medicare beneficiaries who are not covered
by a supplemental drug insurance plan, corporate retirement program,
Medicaid, or a Medicare HMO must use their own money for prescription
drugs taken outside the hospital.
Soumerai and Ross-Degnan propose a joint federalstate program
to cover poor, near-poor, and low-income Medicare beneficiaries,
not eligible for Medicaid, with incomes up to about $16,000 for
a single person. Such a program would target about 4 million elderly
and disabled people with the greatest economic and clinical need,
and would build on the best existing federal and state pharmacy
assistance programs. Their plan also includes federal financial
contributions to states to encourage their participation; lower
patient charges for the lowest-income enrollees; access to a comprehensive
list of effective drugs; and enhanced education of physicians to
reduce over- or under-use of medications.
Soumerai and Ross-Degnan's proposal comes at a time when drug coverage
is fast moving up the agenda in Washington. Congress is starting
to consider controversial plans from Sen. Edward Kennedy (D-Mass.),
Rep. Pete Stark (D-Calif.), and others to offer universal Medicare
drug coverage as well as another bill introduced by Rep. Tom Allen
(D-Maine) to control drug prices. And the National Bipartisan Commission
on the Future of Medicare extended its March 1 deadline so members
could try to devise a major new benefit covering prescription drug
costs.
Drug Benefits Cut, Health Costs Rise
New data in the article show that among Medicare beneficiaries
with incomes less than $10,000, almost two thirds have no drug coverage
and purchase only half as much medication as those with employer
coverage--despite being sicker. With drug expenditures continuing
to escalate, Medicaid programs and managed care organizations across
the U.S. have capped some drug benefits.
Limits on prescription drug benefits have made it more difficult
for the low-income elderly to afford the prescription drugs they
need, which often increases health care costs and may result in
poorer patient outcomes. For example, in New Hampshire, a Medicaid
policy change curtailed unlimited drug coverage to a limit of three
prescriptions per month. While the cap was in effect, excess nursing
home and hospital stays cost Medicaid more than the statewide savings
in drug expenditures.
"Coverage gaps are causing
millions ... to reduce their use of clinically essential medications."
--Stephen Soumerai
"Our studies suggest that coverage gaps are causing millions
of low-income elderly and disabled to reduce their use of clinically
essential medications," says Soumerai, HMS associate professor
of ambulatory care and prevention at Harvard Pilgrim Health Care.
"Our previous research has demonstrated clearly that not only
does this make people sicker, but there are increased hospital and
nursing home admissions, and more costs to the health system as
a whole."
The number of Medicare beneficiaries is projected to grow from
38.6 million in 1997 to 56.3 million in 2017. "Without timely
federal and state Medicare policy reform, the problem of inadequate
coverage for costly prescription drugs among low-income elderly
and disabled Americans will soon become a human and economic catastrophe,"
says Ross-Degnan, HMS assistant professor of ambulatory care and
prevention at Harvard Pilgrim.
The proposal outlined in the New England Journal of Medicine
would cost an estimated $4 billion, which the authors argue
is more achievable than other proposals currently before Congress.
--Peta Gillyatt
Back to Top
|