RESEARCH BRIEFS
Cutting Air Pollution Shown to Save Lives
The highly influential Harvard Six Cities cohort study lasting from 1970
to 1990 linked fine particulate air pollution with increased mortality in
1993. Now a follow-up study examining the same cities and individuals from
1990 to 1998 reinforces the original findings and associates a long-term drop
in air pollution with decreased risk of death. The findings appear in the
March 15 American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine.

Illustration by Rachel Eastwood, based on original courtesy of the EPA
Tiny toxins. Smokestacks and tailpipes produce bits of pollution so
small that about 28 2.5 micrometer particles fit across the diameter of a
single human hair. These particles, composed of acids, metals, and
organic chemicals, flow through the nose and throat into the lungs
and bloodstream, where they cause serious cardiovascular and respiratory
disease.
The original study determined causes of death among 8,096 white adult participants
in six U.S. cities using death certificates. In the same cities, researchers
measured the concentrations of fine particulate matter (PM2.5), particles
smaller than 2.5 micrometers in diameter that form from the emissions
of power plants and automobiles. When inhaled, these minuscule particles
make their
way deep into the lungs and bloodstream, where they have toxic effects.
The study found that as concentrations of fine particles increased,
mortality from lung cancer and cardiopulmonary disease also increased.
Francine Laden, HSPH assistant professor of environmental epidemiology
and HMS assistant professor of medicine at Brigham and Women’s Hospital,
and colleagues continued these observations from 1990 to 1998. The annual
mean PM2.5 concentrations, based on estimates because the original study’s
air-monitoring stations had been removed, decreased in each city, as
did death rates. Using overall averages across the cities and controlling
for an increase
in life expectancy, Laden found that for every µg/m3 decrease in PM2.5
concentrations, death rates dropped by 3 percent, primarily for cardiovascular
and respiratory diseases, two leading causes of death in the United States.
These findings suggest that the adverse effects of long-term PM2.5 on
health may be partly reversible. “Our study shows that if you reduce
pollution, you save lives,” said Laden.
These results came at a crucial
time in air quality policymaking since the Environmental Protection Agency
has proposed new National Ambient
Air Quality Standards, which were open to public comment until April
17. The proposal
keeps annual mean PM2.5 concentration limits at 15 µg/m3 despite recommendations
from the EPA’s board of external scientific advisers to lower limits
to 13 or 14 µg/m3. This study supports the science advisers’ recommendations
that “lower is better,” said Laden.
—Elizabeth Dougherty
Enoxaparin Beats Heparin in Clot-busting Trial
A study in the April 6 New England Journal of Medicine has found
that a new blood-thinning strategy using enoxaparin (Lovenox) is superior
to the standard
blood-thinning strategy using unfractionated heparin when treating heart
attack patients.
When a complete artery blockage causes a heart attack, clearing
that
artery quickly is paramount. “Time is muscle. As each minute ticks
by, some amount of heart tissue becomes irretrievably lost,” said
first author Elliott Antman, HMS professor of medicine at Brigham and Women’s
Hospital. Although many physicians feel the best means of opening the artery
is
angioplasty, not every hospital can perform the procedure. Worldwide,
the most common
treatment is a three-pronged pharmacological clot-busting approach that
involves a drug
to break up the fibrin mesh forming the clot, an antiplatelet drug (usually
aspirin), and an anticoagulant.
This study, enlisting more than 20,000 myocardial
infarction patients from 674 hospitals in 48 countries, examined the
performance of two different
anticoagulant strategies in this pharmacological regimen. The patients
all received fibrinolysis
and aspirin, but were randomized to also receive either standard 48-hour
therapy with unfractionated heparin or enoxaparin as the blood-thinning
component for the duration of hospitalization.
Unfractionated heparin has a variable
effect on coagulation because its
long sugar chains indiscriminately bind to proteins. To ensure proper
dosing, it requires multiple blood-clotting tests each day. The drug must
be administered
in an intravenous infusion and, once treatment stops, the coagulation
cascade sometimes springs back into action and forms new clots.
Enoxaparin, a low–molecular
weight heparin enriched with short sugar chains, has a reliable anticoagulation
effect that requires no monitoring
of the clotting system. It can be administered twice a day by injection,
and no rebound effect has been reported. Enoxaparin has been associated
with more
bleeding than unfractionated heparin, however. The enoxaparin group showed a 17 percent reduction in the risk of death
or nonfatal heart attack and a 26 percent reduction in the need for urgent
revascularization. These findings indicate that for every 1,000 ST-elevated
myocardial infarction patients treated with enoxaparin instead of unfractionated
heparin, there would be 15 fewer nonfatal second heart attacks, seven
fewer bypass surgeries, and six fewer deaths, all at the cost of four additional
episodes of bleeding. Antman and colleagues believe these findings suggest
that doctors should now use enoxaparin instead of unfractionated heparin
when giving clot-busting drugs to heart attack patients.
This double-blind
study required that neither patients nor their doctors knew which treatment
they were receiving, so every patient received either
an IV infusion of unfractionated heparin and placebo injections or
an IV infusion of placebo and enoxaparin injections. These efforts, according
to Antman,
along with independent statistical analysis by HMS researchers, helped
avoid conflicts of interest in the study, which was funded by a grant
from Sanofi-Aventis,
the makers of Lovenox.
—Elizabeth Dougherty
top
|